Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #5148
    Yannick
    Participant

    1. Not so sure, the potential might not be analytically solvable , whereas supposedly a multipole expansion to every order is exactly solvable.

    2.1 The usefullness of the multipole expansion is in cutting it off, if the particular charge distribution at hand is an n+1 pole or doesn’t converge quickly I would think that this limits is usefullness.

    2.2 When the perturbating potential is small compared to a ‘main’ one.

    2.3 I don’t have a good rigourous, quantitative argument but it might seem plausible to expect that given the small size of nucleus compared to the bohr radius , possible inhomogeneities in the charge distribution of the nucleus might have but a small effect on the potential felt by the electrons, do mountains have a measurable effect on the gravitational potential felt by a satellite ? This might be a case for considering it a perturbation. However the multipole expansion I am not so sure.

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.